Bottles & Boobs

It’s OK to Supplement Your Baby: A Pediatrician’s Perspective


by Dr. Jacqueline Winkelmann, a board-certified pediatrician who has been on staff at CHOC Children’s and CHOC Children’s at Mission Hospital in Orange County, California since 2001, where she has held many leadership positions, most recently as Chief-of-Staff and Member of the Board of Directors.

Congratulations! Your bundle of joy is finally here! You’ve prepared for your little one’s arrival for months: nursery is ready, baby clothes are washed, gadgets assembled. You have taken care of yourself and your baby for 9 months: no booze, raw seafood or weird cheeses; you’ve been exercising (OK maybe just walking but that counts) and eating well. And now that baby is here, what next?

Your plan has been to exclusively breastfeed, but what if this is not what’s best for you or your baby? When is it OK to supplement your breastfeeding baby with formula? The first few weeks of an infant’s life are crucial, and exclusive breastfeeding might not be feasible or even advisable. When your expectation as a mom is to exclusively breastfeed, the thought of supplementing  with formula might come with feelings of guilt, fear, and doubt in your ability to feed your baby. Well, let me ease your fears, and reassure you that there is NO need for guilt! 

As pediatricians, our goal is to ensure the health and well-being of your baby, and sometimes that means supplementing, especially during the first weeks of life. The good news is, more research is now showing that “early limited formula supplementation” may in fact preserve successful breastfeeding in the future. 

The Gist

Sometimes breastfed babies need a little formula, especially in the first few weeks of life. This doesn’t have to put an end to your breastfeeding journey and you should feel no guilt for doing what is best for you and your baby.

So, when would a pediatrician recommend supplementation for a breastfed infant?

There are maternal and infant factors that support the decision to supplement a newborn during the first days-week of life. The goal is to avoid hospitalization of a newborn due to insufficient breast milk intake and preserve future breastfeeding.

Maternal factors: these conditions can predispose moms to inadequate early milk supply 

  • Delayed milk production – caused by previous breast surgery, retained placenta or postpartum hemorrhage (Sheehan’s syndrome) 
  • Primary lactation failure -the inability to produce sufficient breast milk, which occurs in 5%- 15% of breastfeeding moms 
  • Intolerable pain when nursing
  • Maternal illness resulting in separation from the infant 
  • Maternal medications considered unsafe  in breastfeeding

Infant factors: supplementation might be indicated if a baby shows any of these signs

  • than 30 minutes (both you and baby are exhausted)
  • Low blood sugar (hypoglycemia) – jittery hands, low body temperature, inconsolable, high-pitched crying
  • Excessive sleepiness – baby is difficult to arouse, lethargic, not waking for feedings every 3 hours
  • Weight loss exceeding 7% at any time but particularly during the first week of life 
  • Signs of dehydration: reduced wet and dirty diapers, no wet diapers in six hours, dry lips and mouth 
  • Significant jaundice – yellowing of the skin and/or eyes, especially below the face

What should you supplement with? How much should you feed your baby at a time?

  • Your baby can be supplemented with your own or donor breast milk or formula. Baby can be supplemented via an SNS tube feeding system, syringe or spoon feeding, or a bottle with a slow flow and a “breastfeeding-friendly” nipple. Make sure to check in with a board-certified lactation consultant.
  • A breastfed baby should be supplemented with 10-15 mL of breast milk or formula per feed. Discuss with your lactation consultant and pediatrician or health care provider.

Stay positive, you’ve got this

Remember, if it has been determined that your baby needs supplementation, even with formula:

  • You are NOT a failure as a mother, and you should feel NO guilt! In fact, you are doing what is best for your baby, so way to go mom!
  • Supplementation will not ruin breastfeeding, in fact, new research shows it might help preserve it.
  • Breastfeeding is not an all or nothing, and any breastfeeding is beneficial to you and your baby. So whatever you decide to do after that first week, your baby thanks you!

Hang in there, things will get easier! Rely on your mother’s instinct and remember you should seek advice but you don’t need to seek permission on how to feed your baby, ever!

The content on this site is for informational purposes only and not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Discuss any health or feeding concerns with your infant's pediatrician. Never disregard professional medical advice or delay it based on the content on this page.

Meet the Author

Jacqueline Winkelmann

Jacqueline Winkelmann, M.D. is supporting Bobbie as a medical expert. A board-certified pediatrician, Doctor Jacq has been in practice for 20 years in Southern California, where she has held many leadership positions, most recently as Hospital Chief-of-Staff and Member of the Board of Directors. Highly accomplished, she was selected as a Top Pediatrician by the International Association of Pediatricians: Leading Physicians of the World in 2018. A national and international speaker on Sports Nutrition, pediatric and adolescent health, Doctor Jacq is also a mom of two that supplemented and believes a pediatrician’s role is to support mothers during their most vulnerable time.

  • Milk Drunk Weekly

    Need a good read while you feed? Keep in the loop with the top pieces from the Milk Drunk team.